We filled out the “Contact Us” form at the bottom of their website expressing our interest in staying there, as there is no online reservation system set up. After making contact and asking a few more questions, we booked one of their 16 rooms for a Monday – Friday stay! The best way to get to Mayaguana is through Bahamasair, and at the time flights only came in twice a week, though they have since added a Wednesday flight as well. We were a bit nervous to not have any sort of reservation number for our stay, and they were also unable to take any sort of payment ahead of time. Instead, we traveled with quite a bit of cash split between our bags to cover the cost of our stay. A week or so before our wedding, we had some trouble getting Baycaner on the phone to confirm our details. After calling a few times, they were happy to let us know that they still had us on their books! This was a huge relief, as there are no other hotels or resorts to stay in on the island.