The episode of Polyphemus ’ cave, and the consequent suffering and demises of his men can be argued as mostly Odysseus’ fault. Odysseus’ men advised him to ‘let them take away some of the cheeses, then come back, drive the kids and lambs quickly out of the pens down to the good ship, and so set sail across the salt water’, but Odysseus ‘was not to be persuaded…though it would have been far better so’. Odysseus lingers about the cave, and is indecisive, then makes the wrong decision to stay in Polyphemus ’ cave, with hope that Polyphemus will display good xenia and bestow upon the men ‘some friendly gifts’. This shows a catastrophic lack of judgement on Odysseus’ part, which eventually ends in Polyphemus devouring two of his men on the spot, and imprisoning the rest. However, Odysseus shows himself to be a good leader, as he plans and executes the blinding of Polyphemus and the men’s escape, which exhibits his intelligence, but he then ruins it by stealing Polyphemus ’ sheep and shouting out ‘derisive words’ to him, boasting about his triumph. In his pride and conceit, Odysseus reveals his true identity to Polyphemus , which angers him further and causes him to tell his father, Poseidon, that Odysseus had blinded him, which engenders Poseidon’s rage, which cause suffering for Odysseus’ men. No one but Odysseus can be blamed for this – his men try to ‘restrain and pacify’ him, to no avail. Odysseus’ hamartia (his arrogance) directly causes his men suffering; he is the one responsible. here