The other day I was in a Tractor Supply Co. store and happened past their o-rings. A package of o-rings caught my eye that looked to be just about the same size as my drain plug gasket. I was curious and they were only $2, and were spec'd for water, grease, oil, etc., so I bought them on a lark. When I got them home, I'll be daggone if they're not just about *exactly* the same size as the crush gasket. Same outer diameter and same thickness.. I had to pull the drain plug anyway, so I went ahead and stuck one on the drain plug just to see if it would go up in the inset without hanging over and having plug itself pinching it in half of something like that. it fit perfectly. I tightened it down and it got really snug.. I pulled it again right away to inspect it for damage, and it was actually kinda difficult to get back out.. The plug itself seemed tighter in the hole, and I had to hook the o-ring with a smaller screwdriver to get it back out.. And it didn't look like it was marred or anything like that from installing it and tightening the plug on top of it.